Potential Halachic Pitfalls in Home Construction and Remodeling


by STAR-K

 

Mazal tov! Whether you have just purchased your very first house, the lot on which you’re building one from scratch, or you’ve finally saved up money to renovate your 70-year-old home, let the buyer/builder/remodeler beware! This is not your grandfather’s house! The average Torah-observant consumer would have to have a thorough understanding of things like electricity and plumbing – and their applications vis-à-vis halacha – to ensure that their newfangled home improvements providing safety, comfort, and convenience are also Torah-compliant. These include everything from comfort pumps to induction stovetops.

Comfort Pump Perks

Comfort Pumps (aka recirculation pumps) are popular in large houses because, in addition to their easy installation onto established plumbing, they can decrease water waste by thousands of gallons per year and can save you up to 10% on your water bill. They also offer less wait time for warm water that could normally take five to seven minutes to travel from your hot water heater to your faucets. Their special options include continuous run, timer- or thermostat-activated, or motion sensor.

How do they work? Think of a comfort pump, installed on your hot water heater, as a recycler of already heated water. The pump sends water back to the heater to be reheated and recirculated. Hot water is sent through your pipes while simultaneously pulling hot water from the heater and sending cool water away from hot water lines and back to the water heater. It can be accessed by any sink or faucet in your home.

 

Comfort Pump Halachic Pitfalls

Many people don’t even realize that they have a comfort pump in their house. You can tell that you have one by looking at your hot water heater; the pump is visible. The halachic issue with comfort pumps is that they run the hot water around the house by running it through the cold water. Normally, if you don’t want to turn on the hot water on Shabbos, you simply don’t, and this problem is avoided, but with a comfort pump, when you turn on the cold water, it is as if you are turning on the hot water. If you’re not a plumber, you’re not going to understand it, but the bottom line is that a comfort pump causes you to use hot water on Shabbos. So, you must find a way to avoid this. Call STAR-K (410-484-4110) to help you find a solution.

Basement Ejector Pump Perks

Basement ejector pumps (aka sewage ejector pumps) move wastewater and solids from a basement to the main sewer line or septic tank, since gravity cannot move wastewater from below-grade areas. Without one, accumulated wastewater can cause clogged pipes, sewage backups, sewer gas in the home, unpleasant odors, and bacteria growth.

How do they work? A float switch detects when the water level in the ejector pit, which is usually dug underground in the basement floor, reaches a certain height and turns on the pump. This signals the pump to send the wastewater up to the sewer or septic line. The pump turns off when the water level in the pit drops. The downside is that they can be prone to clogging and jamming from solid waste, such as toilet paper.

 Basement Ejector Pump Halachic Pitfalls

Harav Moshe Heinemann, shlit”a, holds that a basement ejector pump should not be used on Shabbos unless you can set it up in such a way that you know, by flushing it, that you will not be causing its electric motor to go on. It is important to consult STAR-K (or your local Orthodox rabbi), regarding circumventing this problem so it can be used on Shabbos. 

Smart Security Systems

There are numerous components you can choose for your smart security system, and sensors are the most important part of it. They enable you to know what is going on in every area of your home, and they enable you to set up routines to help you better manage your life. 

There are glass break sensors, tilt sensors, motion sensors, flood sensors, fire and smoke sensors/detectors, and window/door sensors. 

Security cameras on smart systems add an extra level to your security. They offer two-way talk features, built-in sirens, or security lights that can activate when motion is detected. Nowadays, most security system brands offer smart home devices beyond sensors and cameras. They include smart door locks, doorbell cameras, smart thermostats, smart garage door openers, and smart medical alert items. Insurers offer discounts on home policies to those who have smart security systems. 

Halachic Pitfalls of Smart Security Systems and Other Smart Technology

RING alarms and doorbells have motion sensors. When you press the doorbell or simply walk past it, you are causing it to light up by triggering the motion sensor. There is a way to turn the sensors off; you just must remember to do it before Shabbos/Yom Tov. Other smart home technology, such as smart thermostats made by Nest and Ecobee, help homeowners save on heat and air conditioning bills. They both have proximity sensors and passive motion sensors that are triggered when a person gets close or passes by the thermostat. These can be disabled, but advance planning is needed, especially if you are a renter or short-term guest, to make sure you don’t wind up being too hot or too cold over Shabbos or Yom Tov. There are various ways these problems can be avoided. Here, too, one should consult STAR-K (or your local Orthodox rabbi). Uncertified Sabbath Modes

If you are buying new appliances for your kitchen, here is some important pre-purchase appliance advice.

Appliance manufacturers, with the aid of modern technology, have designed kitchen appliances to be safer and more efficient while incorporating various features to enhance operation. However, the integration of this technology can pose a challenge to their proper use on Shabbos and Yom Tov. For this reason, in 1997, a historic technological project was launched between a major appliance manufacturer and STAR-K Kosher Certification. Prior to that time, many of their appliances did not conform to halachic guidelines. Whirlpool Corporation (manufacturers of KitchenAid, Maytag and more) approached STAR-K to help modify their ovens for use on Shabbos and Yom Tov. Following some adjustments, a successful mode was developed. Whirlpool called it a “Sabbath Mode” and was awarded a patent in 1998 for this concept. Subsequently, some technologically advanced refrigerators also acquired Sabbath Mode certification. How does Sabbath Mode work? Today’s ovens have a safety feature that automatically shuts the oven off after 12 hours of operation. Sabbath Mode ovens are specially designed to bypass many of the practical and halachic problems posed by the modern oven. When in “Sabbath Mode,” no lights, digits, solenoids, fans, icons, tones, or displays will be activated or modified during normal use.(Important note: Sabbath Mode does not permit us to turn these appliances on or off during Shabbos or Yom Tov, nor does it allow us to use these appliances completely at will on Shabbos or Yom Tov. Rather, it enables us to use these appliances within the guidelines of halacha as posted on the STAR-K website: www.star-k.org.)Consumers should be aware, however, that some appliance companies are advertising “Sabbath Mode” oven features that are not certified by STAR-K or any other reputable rabbinical group. To be sure that all halachic concerns have been duly addressed, you can check model numbers from specific manufacturers on the STAR-K website or call the STAR-K office.

Induction Stovetops

Nowadays, everyone wants to have an induction stovetop, rather than a gas or electric one. Although an induction stovetop is acclaimed by Consumer Reports for boiling water 20 to 40% faster than tested gas and traditional electric cooktops, and for its electromagnetic field providing more precise, even heating compared to traditional cooktops, it may not be the wisest choice for your kosher kitchen construction or remodel. 

An induction burner does not produce any heat of its own. Rather, when turned on, it simply activates a magnetic field. Placing an induction-compatible pot or pan onto the element is what activates the heating process; removing it immediately stops it. Consequently, there are some halachic issues that arise regarding their usage on Yom Tov and Shabbos.

Yom Tov: On an ordinary electric or gas cooktop, the burners can be turned on before Yom Tov; you are able to cook on them as needed for that Yom Tov. It would be useless to leave an induction stovetop burner on before Yom Tov, because the cooking connection is only made when you put the pot or pan on the burner. Since there is a connect and disconnect of the current each time the pot is placed on or removed from the burner, it is assur (forbidden) to use an induction cooktop for Yom Tov.

Shabbos: There are two reasons why an induction stovetop would not work for Shabbos useto cook cholent on it, for example. Removing the cholent pot from the stovetop would cause it to turn off. Putting a blech on any glass cooktop would not only cause it to shatter, it would also interrupt the magnetic connection between the cooking element and the pot.

When Fences Are Required

Last, but not least, the roofs, porches, balconies, and landings of your home must be Torah compliant as well. This is in accordance with the pasuk found in Parshas Ki-Setze: “When you build a new house, then make a fence for your roof…” The object of this positive mitzva is to prevent a person from accidentally falling, as the pasuk continues, “…And you shall not put blood in your house, lest someone fall from there.” 

Under which circumstances is a person obligated to erect a maakeh (fence)? A maakeh is typically required at the edge of any floor that people walk on, if the floor is more than 10 tefachim  (31.5 to 37.9 inches, depending on your rav’s psak) above the ground or above the next floor. The fence itself must be at least 10 tefachim tall. Typical situations requiring a fence include balconies, sun decks, and front and back porches whose floors are more than 40 inches from the ground. 

It has come to our attention that the porches on many homes in the Torah community are more than 40 inches from the ground, but the porch rails are almost never the required height of a kosher maakeh. This measurement is almost 40 inches according to the Chazon Ish, but we use 40 inches to keep things simple. A maakeh must also be strong enough that a person could lean against it without falling. Finally, the maakeh must be constructed such that it does not have gaps through which a child could fall. To learn more about this important halacha, see Rabbi Mordechai Frankel’s article, “Halacha of Erecting a Fence Around a Roof,” at https://www.star-k.org/articles/kashrus-kurrents/5295/insights-from-the-institute-8/.  

Hopefully, this article has enlightened homeowners about halachic considerations when building or renovating their homes, so not only the food they eat but the homes they live in are “kosher.”

 

comments powered by Disqus